Watch order of the phoenix on
However, I think she did know that they aren't "kind or docile" and that Umbridge would resort to insulting them and acting superior. I agree that Hermione has been used as a way to convey information because she is intelligent, but I think that her knowing something the audience doesn't or isn't going to learn is irrelevant and impossible to prove. It is worth arguing, then, that Hermione would know the violent history of centaurs and took Umbrdige into the forest knowing that she would suffer rape at the hands of a very violent group of half-men half-horses.
![watch order of the phoenix on watch order of the phoenix on](https://www.xappie.com/image.php?width=209&height=311&image=./uploads/ott/profile_tt0373889.jpg)
Rowling has made a point of using Hermione to provide the readers with information because she is considered to be very knowledgeable. In fact, they were always very straightforward in their disdain for non-centaurs. I'd just like to add a few responses to this article.Īccording to centaur legend, they are not the docile, kind, and all-knowing creatures that Rowling chose to portray them as.Īside from Firenze, I don't remember the centaurs in Harry Potter ever being docile or kind.
Only Rowling knows for sure, so the author of the article should stop pretending that this is something that undoubtedly occurred.Īnd what is this nonsense of an upcoming article about Harry Potter gay-bashing? Does she not realize that Dumbledore is homosexual? I feel like you'd really have to be reaching far to imagine that Harry Potter is anti-gay. Rowling wanted people to wonder if that's what was going on, not necessarily that it actually happened. If you weren't, then you can just assume that Umbridge was roughed up, and only reacted with fear later because she was afraid of being attacked by what she saw as "monsters" again. If you were already aware of the centaur myths, it's meant to make you wonder. Rowling purposely wrote that scene with the intention of being vague about what happened. The writer of the article asserts that this theory is a fact, but there is no real guarantee that it happened, it's only implied.
![watch order of the phoenix on watch order of the phoenix on](https://media.giphy.com/media/7rSqa74vJW0Te/200.gif)
Dueling - For all your trivia-related needs.
#WATCH ORDER OF THE PHOENIX ON MODS#
#WATCH ORDER OF THE PHOENIX ON FULL#
The expanded, full rules can be found here: Full Rules Events Help the mods enforce these rules by reporting posts and comments that violate them! Follow reddit's rules and " reddiquette".If you want to get a house crest and/or title by your username, or gain access to your common room, please check here for instructions. Currently in discussion week Have a question about the series? Check out our commonly asked questions here before you post!